Wednesday, May 19, 2004

Manmohan looks set to be PM

With the backing of Sonia Gandhi, it seems as if Manmohan Singh will be the next Prime Minister of India. How do I feel about this? Well, slightly ambivalent. Obviously his selection has done wonders for the stock market, which, as I said in my last post, confuses me. But that apart, he has no popular base of any sort. I suspect he will be another Gujral kind of Prime Minister. Also, am not sure what his views on most issues- e.g. Pakistan, allying (or not) with US, and so on are. I guess only time will tell. Take a look at this article, for a good summary of events yesterday- it also contains a potted bio of Manmohan at the end.

In a related development, the DMK has decided to join the government, while the Left still resolutely stays away. This could really be the biggest blunder the Left has made in many years. If they wish to extend their sphere of influence outside West Bengal and Kerala, this was the prime opportunity to do so. I am not sure what calculations the high command has made- perhaps they think keeping out of power will save them from anti incumbency? But the truth is that if you see the last election as a series of smaller local elections, then this argument would fall through. Also, for two states that need development badly, the Left could have pushed some of its agenda through if it had more clout.

In Tamil Nadu, where Jayalalitha is probably still reeling from the election results, she has decided to give a number of sops to placate the people. Although the Hindu has praised her for listening to the voice of the people, I am not so sure. She is obviously doing whatever it takes to cling on to power, she hasn't grown democratic tentacles over night. And her withdrawal of cases against the media on charges of defamation proves that- it's not a 'democratic' move, it's just a desperate attemtp to silence her critics.

Finally, what are the implications of what Sonia has done, her stunning political sacrifice?? The Telegraph today suggests that there is a groundswell of opinion from the stock market supporting her decision. She's probably come off better in this exchange with the BJP. It makes her look as if she's not hungry for power, it removes the last real 'issue' that the BJP could have raised and ensures that even her detractors have nothing to say. George Fernandes' comment last night about her 'changing her mind' sounds like sour grapes now- after all she changed her mind, because parts of the NDA threatened to agitate and bring the country to a halt. Further, the NDA decision to attend the swearing in ceremony too looks rather stupid in the light of Sonia's fairly dignified statement. I suspect that underneath her political inexperience, lies a very very shrewd politician.

3 Comments:

Blogger BeeDee said...

Hi Suvrat,

Look first, why bother with what the NYT has to say. I mean, if the US does or doesn't like the PM (and this is the NYT not the US govt!) it doesn't matter does it? My close analysis of Western media coverage has shown that people are remarkably ignorant about Indian politics- beyond a few broad generalizations. So as you've argued elsewhere, maybe we should look at the Indian media more closely.

Second, you argue that the stock markets doing well is an indication that the 'elites' are pleased hence it is not a good sign. But as I keep saying there is this contradiction. The stock markets crashed because Manmohan was going to be FM, with I assume the same reform agenda. The very same elites who are pleased that he is PM, were not pleased that he was going to be FM. Also again today the stock mark plunged. I'm no economist, the stock market has never made much sense to me, and I don't own any stocks. But honestly what's happened this week seems fairly irrational. I just took a look at the stock markets before posting this btw, they're very unstable, and not looking too good. But by your logic we'd have to conclude that the elites don't think their interests will be protected and that's a good thing. So not sure if this stock market logic if yours is very sound.

best,
Antara

11:43 AM  
Blogger BeeDee said...

Tomu,
Don't recall your logic EVER being sound!
Ok, so explain to me: you say that Indian stock brokers are happy= elites are happy= bad news for ordinary people. So how do u explain the huge crash that happened the other day? The worst crash since 1992. By your logic that should mean= elites are unhappy= good news for ordinary people. But how true is that...given that it crashed because of a Congress govt which is bound to be pro-reform? I am not sure I get this stock market logic of ours at all.
A.

8:33 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree with you, and I've suspected it all along. Sonia Gandhi is an extremely shrewd politician and has a well-thought out, long term perspective.

6:58 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home